South Africans refuse to innovate, and love to imitate

Billions of people are now for the first time being touched by technology; untapped markets like gold mines stretch as far as your eyes can see, from Cape to Cairo and beyond. They sit there waiting, and we read about them everyday, yet young technology entrepreneurs are fantasizing about building the next big thing to hit the US Apple app store.
I sometimes find myself completely numb when young South African developers and entrepreneurs talk about how their next project will be a web app or  iPad app thing. Have we all completely lost the plot?
It seems that perhaps our Silicon Valley envy has impeded our thinking in South Africa. We are completely obsessed with the American market and what American developers are doing, to the point where we have been blinded to reality.
It’s not just developers either, the problem stretches all the way to CEOs of our local corporates aswell. I always find it amusing when I see South African companies investing their marketing budget into iPhone apps when the vast majority of their customers have never seen a computer.
We are all unwittingly complicit in a conspiracy against our own well-being. Millions of South Africans are walking around with problems that are not being addressed by South African developers and entrepreneurs. Hundreds of millions of Africans are walking around with cellular phones but have never heard of Pepsi or Lay’s chips because marketers don’t give a damn about them and are too busy building iPad apps.
We should start innovating in South Africa, because we are lagging behind in a huge way. The proliferation of cheap smartphones and the insane addiction to telecommunication that our people have, leaves us with no excuse. The people want it, we need to start giving it to them.
For a long time mobile was mostly text based then later on as browsers came to phones nothing more than a stripped-down ugly html pages. With the dramatic surge in Android devices in emerging markets this is no longer the face of mobile, mobile in Africa is completely changing and in the next year will be unrecognisable to those looking on apathetically from the side-lines.
It’s time we stop imitating what companies and developers are doing in saturated developed markets, we need to go back to our pioneering roots and take the lead in these new untapped markets around the world though innovation and entrepreneurship.
Disclosure: Opinions by writers are just that ““ opinions. They do not necessarily reflect the views of Bandwidth Blog.

  1. I definitely think that there is an emerging large and hungry market here in Africa in the mobile space. Surprisingly we see very few pitches at 4Di Capital relating to this.

  2. I think the pervasiveness of cloning American startups isn’t just a South African thing. Recently read a post on Berlin’s startup culture and it is just as prevalent. http://www.wired.co.uk/magazine/archive/2011/09/european-startups/berlin.
    We don’t see all the clones in Europe and even America, because they don’t make news, while in South Africa it is more evident, because it is closer to home.
    I do feel in South Africa (and as part of the African continent) have unique problems that could spill over into the rest of the world (such as innovating in the mobile space).

    1. thanks for the comment, yeah it’s definitely a problem the exists everywhere. I feel in SA we have a really awesome opportunity, it’s just up to us to leading instead of following.

  3. I don’t know enough about mobile to have a strong opinion. But I can appreciate the sentiment. Imitation is not innovation. 
    Yet when you actually look at it, its not really just the mobile/tech/tweetcano space.
    M-NET started with not that many subscribers and a whole lot of the country/continent without T.V’s or the ability to pay subscriptions. Then came DSTV/PVR/ON-Demand…ect. 
    They never had to really innovate, just take their cues from overseas (pure imitation). 
    But its worked out pretty well for Naspers and who can blame them.
    Like I said, know nothing about mobile. But can appreciate the article, as well as those that imitate innovation. 

    1. Thanks for the comment Gerald. In my opinion we would be doing our part even if we just started utilizing the technology people already have and address their needs and wants. It doesn’t need to be a mind-blowing revolutionary idea, we just need to start solving African problems and stop targeting American issues.

  4.  How is a local market innovator meant to compete with R+D teams of a global player? Innovating is not as smart as imitating in any local context unless the localisation is a key differentiator.
    That said innovation is a core value at WA 🙂 It’s just done on a smaller scale, and unlikely to be *globally* innovative.

    1. Disruptive products in tech have a history of being built in basements in the face of competition from large multinationals (eg. Apple/IBM), and in software the barrier to entry is even lower.

  5.  How is a local market innovator meant to compete with R+D teams of a global player? Innovating is not as smart as imitating in any local context unless the localisation is a key differentiator.
    That said innovation is a core value at WA 🙂 It’s just done on a smaller scale, and unlikely to be *globally* innovative.

  6.  How is a local market innovator meant to compete with R+D teams of a global player? Innovating is not as smart as imitating in any local context unless the localisation is a key differentiator.
    That said innovation is a core value at WA 🙂 It’s just done on a smaller scale, and unlikely to be *globally* innovative.

  7.  How is a local market innovator meant to compete with R+D teams of a global player? Innovating is not as smart as imitating in any local context unless the localisation is a key differentiator.
    That said innovation is a core value at WA 🙂 It’s just done on a smaller scale, and unlikely to be *globally* innovative.

    1. You do not compete with them. Who is most likely to know how to solve African problems other than the Africans.. 

  8. I think the biggest hurdle at the moment is justifying the costs and risks involved in developing an app for a large, established market vs an emerging and as yet uncertain one. 
    Yes, the African market is growing, and yes, there is a definite need for apps to solve specific problems. The challenges involved in developing those apps however, make it a risky and therefore less attractive option if all you’re interested in is making a quick buck – which let’s face it is the purpose behind most (not all) mobile apps.

    1. Totally agreed, but we both also know that building an Android app in your spare time is not going to end up in you being broke. All I’m saying is *try*, we waste so much time on other things online already, why not experiment?

  9. We do mobile (smartphone) development, and we definitely see our biggest opportunities in the African market, and specifically on the  Android platform.  You are right, there’s a huge gap for innovative developers that can solve African problems.  Western developers don’t want to or know how to think in the African context, and there’s a huge lack of skills in Africa itself.  So if you can fulfil both criteria (think African and skillful), there are many opportunities out there.

Comments are closed.